Situation: Government regulation now limits pricing power in 3 sub-industries: electric utilities, long-distance railroad and truck transportation, and money-center banks. First it was electric utilities, then railroads and trucking. The purpose of this regulation was to ensure that these companies with high fixed costs would be able to maintain their networks. That meant customers had to be charged enough to keep Return on Equity at around 10%. Railroads and electric utilities are essentially monopolies, so regulators also prevent them from overcharging. Then the Great Recession came along, and the few investment banking firms that had existed prior to the Lehman Panic couldn’t remain solvent. To gain access to Federal protection, they applied to become commercial banks. That had the down-side of welcoming Federal auditors into their offices on a full-time basis. When the “other shoe dropped” (The Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act of 2010), legislation imposed additional regulation on the riskier (and more lucrative) financial products that money center banks prefer to promote. The danger is that these interconnected megabanks would simultaneously lose a great deal of money, i.e., precipitate a global economic crisis. Dodd-Frank calls those banks “SIFIs” or “Systemically Important Financial Institutions." The point is that most of the levers controlling finance are no longer located near Wall Street. They’re in Washington. So, there may be more safety in investing with companies in those 3 sub-industries that fall under Federal protection. Think of them as government protected companies.
Mission: We take the gambler’s saying seriously, i.e., “when possible, bet with the house.” The House is now the US Treasury, which has controlled short-term interest rates through the Federal Open Market Committee since the Banking Act of 1933. That’s one key variable that controls stock prices. The other key variable is earnings growth, which is supposed to be a function of the private economy. But, pricing power of 3 sub-industries is now under oversight of the US Treasury or government agencies answerable to the US Treasury. To “bet with the house” we need to assess a sample of companies in those 3 sub-industries.
Execution: We look at the 65-stock Dow Jones Composite Index (^DJA) to find a representative sample of companies. This week’s Table has every company in those 3 sub-industries that is large enough to appear in the 2015 Barron’s 500 List, as long as it has an S&P bond rating of BBB+ or better and an S&P stock rating of B+/M.
Bottom Line: These 11 companies operate under close government regulation. As a group, they have done well compared to the lowest-cost S&P 500 Index fund (compare Lines 13, 22 and 26 under Columns C, E and N in the Table). This outperformance apparently comes with no additional risk (see the same Lines under Columns D, I and O in the Table), So, betting with the House looks like a good idea. Specifically, this 11-stock sample performs better than the 65-stock Dow Jones Composite Index (compare Lines 13, 20 and 25 in Columns C through F of the Table) which, in turn, performs better than VFINX (the lowest-cost S&P 500 Index fund at Line 22 of the Table).
Risk Rating: 6
Full Disclosure: I dollar-average into NEE, UNP and JPM.
Note: Metrics are current for the Sunday of publication; metrics in red denote underperformance relative to our key benchmark, the Vanguard Balanced Index Fund (VBINX).
Post questions and comments in the box below or send email to: irv.mcquarrie@InvestTuneRetire.com
Invest your funds carefully. Tune investments as markets change. Retire with confidence.
Sunday, November 29
Sunday, November 22
Week 229 - Stocks with 5-30 Years of Risk vs. Reward Data That Beat the S&P 500 Index
Situation: In last week’s blog (see Week 228), we turned up 6 “unicorns” (stocks with above-market returns and below market risk) over 5-16 yr holding periods. This week we’ve extended the holding period out to 30 yrs. Once again we turned up 6 unicorns (see Table) but 3 of those weren’t on last week’s list. In other words, only 3 companies in the 2015 Barron’s 500 List have outperformed the S&P 500 Index over 5, 16 and 30 yr periods while presenting the investor with a less risk than the S&P 500 Index. Those companies are Kimberly-Clark (KMB), NextEra Energy (NEE), and DTE Energy (DTE). Aside from investing in such minimally risky “defensive” stocks, you would do better by investing in the broad diversification of a low-cost S&P 500 Index fund like the Vanguard 500 Index Fund (VFINX). Or, you can seek higher returns by taking on more risk!
Mission: Develop a logical plan to have your stock portfolio outperform the S&P 500 Index by taking on more risk.
Execution: Academic studies of this problem have shown that you have two options:
1) pick stocks issued by 40+ large-capitalization companies that represent all 10 S&P industries, while avoiding those with long-term debt (see Week 158);
2) pick a low-cost stock index fund that represents the next most risky layer of the market, i.e., mid-capitalization companies covered by the S&P 400 Index. There is an exchange-traded fund that will do that for you, the SPDR MidCap 400 ETF Trust (MDY at Line 16 in the Table).
Bottom Line: If you want to beat the S&P 500 Index, you’ll have to take on more risk. Why? Because there are only 3 stocks that have had better risk-adjusted performance than the S&P 500 Index over the past 5, 16 and 30 yrs (KMB, NEE, DTE). That’s not enough! Academic studies have shown that you need to diversify your holdings across all 10 S&P industries in order to spread out risk that occurs in downturns. This means you need to hold upwards of 40 stocks in your portfolio to avoid “concentration” risk. Or, you can pick a mid-capitalization stock index fund (e.g. MDY) and save yourself a lot of trouble. Over the past 5-yr holding period, that choice would have given you better returns than the Vanguard S&P 500 Index fund (VFINX) but with a greater risk of loss (compare Lines 15 and 16 at Columns C, D and I of the Table). Over a 30-yr holding period (with regular additions through dollar-cost averaging), the returns are again greater for the Mid-Cap fund (see Lines 19 & 20 at Column M in the Table) but the risk of loss is significantly lower (see Column O at Lines 19 & 20 in the Table). This is a logical way to beat the S&P 500 Index without taking on more risk. Holding periods of 16, 20 and 25 yrs will also do that for you, per the BMW Method. Why does a Mid-Cap stock index carry less long-term risk than the S&P 500 Index? Because smaller companies have less access to long-term financing through bond sales. In other words, Mid-Cap companies have choppier earnings growth than S&P 500 companies, and are still establishing their brands. So, they are less able to attract a syndicate of banks that will back the issuance of a long-term bond with an interest rate that is lower than the company’s ROA (Return on Assets). Having no long-term debt means there is little chance of a company going bankrupt (or being acquired by another company for less than book value).
Risk Rating: 6 (because MDY will always have a higher 5-yr Beta than VFINX, which has a Risk Rating of 5, as will any broadly diversified collection of 40+ stocks).
Full Disclosure: I dollar-average into NEE.
Note: Metrics are brought current for the Sunday of publication; metrics highlighted in red denote underperformance vs. the Vanguard Balanced Index Fund (VBINX).
Post questions and comments in the box below or send email to: irv.mcquarrie@InvestTuneRetire.com
Mission: Develop a logical plan to have your stock portfolio outperform the S&P 500 Index by taking on more risk.
Execution: Academic studies of this problem have shown that you have two options:
1) pick stocks issued by 40+ large-capitalization companies that represent all 10 S&P industries, while avoiding those with long-term debt (see Week 158);
2) pick a low-cost stock index fund that represents the next most risky layer of the market, i.e., mid-capitalization companies covered by the S&P 400 Index. There is an exchange-traded fund that will do that for you, the SPDR MidCap 400 ETF Trust (MDY at Line 16 in the Table).
Bottom Line: If you want to beat the S&P 500 Index, you’ll have to take on more risk. Why? Because there are only 3 stocks that have had better risk-adjusted performance than the S&P 500 Index over the past 5, 16 and 30 yrs (KMB, NEE, DTE). That’s not enough! Academic studies have shown that you need to diversify your holdings across all 10 S&P industries in order to spread out risk that occurs in downturns. This means you need to hold upwards of 40 stocks in your portfolio to avoid “concentration” risk. Or, you can pick a mid-capitalization stock index fund (e.g. MDY) and save yourself a lot of trouble. Over the past 5-yr holding period, that choice would have given you better returns than the Vanguard S&P 500 Index fund (VFINX) but with a greater risk of loss (compare Lines 15 and 16 at Columns C, D and I of the Table). Over a 30-yr holding period (with regular additions through dollar-cost averaging), the returns are again greater for the Mid-Cap fund (see Lines 19 & 20 at Column M in the Table) but the risk of loss is significantly lower (see Column O at Lines 19 & 20 in the Table). This is a logical way to beat the S&P 500 Index without taking on more risk. Holding periods of 16, 20 and 25 yrs will also do that for you, per the BMW Method. Why does a Mid-Cap stock index carry less long-term risk than the S&P 500 Index? Because smaller companies have less access to long-term financing through bond sales. In other words, Mid-Cap companies have choppier earnings growth than S&P 500 companies, and are still establishing their brands. So, they are less able to attract a syndicate of banks that will back the issuance of a long-term bond with an interest rate that is lower than the company’s ROA (Return on Assets). Having no long-term debt means there is little chance of a company going bankrupt (or being acquired by another company for less than book value).
Risk Rating: 6 (because MDY will always have a higher 5-yr Beta than VFINX, which has a Risk Rating of 5, as will any broadly diversified collection of 40+ stocks).
Full Disclosure: I dollar-average into NEE.
Note: Metrics are brought current for the Sunday of publication; metrics highlighted in red denote underperformance vs. the Vanguard Balanced Index Fund (VBINX).
Post questions and comments in the box below or send email to: irv.mcquarrie@InvestTuneRetire.com
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)